In some hospitals, the ultrasound transducer has already surpassed the stethoscope as the tool of choice for front-line physicians to examine patients. The traditional stethoscope exam of the lungs with auscultation, percussion, and palpation, even when combined with a chest X-ray, is limited in comparison to a bedside lung ultrasound exam.
Dr. Nilam Soni, MD, FHM, FACP, is an academic hospitalist and associate professor at the University of Texas Health Science Center in San Antonio who has a passion for teaching bedside ultrasound. He’s co-written Point-of-Care Ultrasound, a comprehensive textbook for providers that includes over 250 videos and five chapters dedicated to lung ultrasound.
While bedside or point-of-care ultrasound is common practice among a few specialties, such as emergency medicine, Dr. Soni says, it has yet to be widely adopted. With training, a lung ultrasound exam can be performed by anyone—a pediatrician, internist, or surgeon—who listens to the lungs.
Many medical facilities already own the equipment needed to perform a lung ultrasound exam—a portable ultrasound machine with a phased array transducer. While busy physicians may believe the stethoscope exam is adequate, there are good reasons to adopt lung ultrasound into the front line evaluation of patients.
Here are five ways lung ultrasound benefits patients and providers:
More accurate diagnoses than chest X-rays
“When you have an obscured lower lobe of the lung on chest X-ray and the X-ray appears white, you don’t know if it represents a pneumonia, effusion, elevated hemidiaphragm, or even a tumor or mass,” says Dr. Soni. “With ultrasound, within seconds, you get the answer. You can determine what the opacified area on the X-ray represents. It facilitates making a diagnosis and treating the patient.”
Better patient management for shorter hospital stays
“You can also look at the upper lobes of the lungs and see if the patient has pulmonary edema within a few seconds,” Dr. Soni says. “With pulmonary edema, they have heart failure and need diuretics; if they have pneumonia, they need antibiotics. The gamut of treatment is quite broad and a physical exam is really limited at differentiating these conditions. It’s so much easier to put the ultrasound transducer on their chest and see what’s going on.”
Reduced exposure to radiation
“Lung ultrasound doesn’t give patients the radiation of a CT scan. When we run people through CT scanners, we give them a lot of radiation, 150 times the radiation of an X-ray. You want to avoid unnecessary CT scans with chronically ill patients, especially children with chronic illnesses, because we know that cumulative radiation exposure can cause more cancers,” says Dr. Soni.
“We’re gathering more data, but there’s enough data on diagnostic accuracy justifying the use of lung ultrasound – it’s superior to chest x-rays and comparable to CT scans of the chest.”
See related article on risk of cancer associated with CT scans. (http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-much-ct-scans-increase-risk-cancer/)
Better patient satisfaction
“From a patient satisfaction standpoint, many patients enjoy seeing on the screen the pathology or what you are talking about in their lungs,” says Dr. Soni. “I think it has pulled physicians back to the bedside more than any other technology, which is what most patients want. We’re talking to the patient as we perform a bedside ultrasound exam, getting more history and more data. It has been well studied that there are fewer complications and likely more comfort for the patient when procedures are performed with ultrasound guidance.”
More physician confidence in their treatment plans
“As for physicians, we’re able to initiate more appropriate therapies on the front line than before. We can also make more appropriate work-ups and consultations at the time of admission. If you see a pleural effusion, and if it’s free-flowing, it can be drained easily with thoracentesis. But if it’s a severely loculated, you need to place a chest tube and most likely consult with a pulmonologist or surgeon,” Dr. Soni says.
“The bottom line is we realize how much we were missing and how much more data we can get on what we suspected, as well as what we didn’t expect, and all of this is done rapidly at the bedside. Once physicians start using it, they realize quickly how much better their practices have become, and they will never go back to practicing without ultrasound.”